What is it like to negotiate with Russian officials regarding the conflict in Ukraine?
This question has generated widespread curiosity following multiple recent rounds of ceasefire talks, which have so far appeared to yield little progress half a decade after the comprehensive invasion.
Another round of American-facilitated negotiations is expected to occur in Geneva later this week. In preparation, a key member of the Ukrainian leadership's delegation, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has been involved in the latest direct military talks, has provided his perspective.
According to Kyslytsya, these dealings are business-like and generally free of the type of ideological and rhetorical posturing seen elsewhere by Russian leadership.
"The military have a better grasp of what is going on in the combat zone," he stated in a meeting earlier this week.
"The question remains if they [the Russians] are capable, or not, of relaying information accurately…without cooking or distorting the information," he continued.
It is far from an simple task to try to end a war. The nature of the front line in the Donbas region - where thousands of drones operate and kill over a huge so-called "contested area" separating the opposing forces, while two hundred thousand local residents still live in the "fortress belt" cities of the eastern region - renders the technical process of separation extremely complicated.
"It is essential to establish a precise framework of rules and protocols," the diplomat said, "and a way to verify and oversee."
The Role of International Parties
A great deal of this work, he said, is finished, partly due to the direct participation of US representatives, such as General Alexus Grynkewich and a high-ranking Army official.
It's obviously against Kyiv's benefit to criticise representatives of the American government, but when he praises the American team for its work, he comes across as sincere.
"We must credit the US side for their dedication and their patience," he says, "because they sit in the sessions continuously. They don't only watch…they put inquiries and they listen to our responses."
The negotiator was similarly positive about the roles played by the former president's adviser, whom he referred to as "not a novice", and wealthy envoy Steve Witkoff, whom he characterized as "a much wiser individual than the caricature image you see in the press".
The US, Kyslytsya said, will undertake a key role in overseeing any potential ceasefire, with capabilities including satellite and other forms of advanced surveillance.
"It is necessary to have someone who will play the role of adjudication, for the reason that if there is a breach there should be a third party that is solid [and] respected."
Previous and Present Monitoring Challenges
For eight years prior to the major invasion in 2022, this oversight function was handled by the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe - a group whose limited resources and lack of enforcement mechanisms made it mostly unable of preventing an escalation.
"It was quite an achievement [for them] simply to have a couple of drones airborne over the area," Kyslytsya commented. "It resembles the stone age era compared to what we have today."
By contrast, latest analyses indicate that up to 12,000 unmanned aircraft are operating over the urban center of a frontline city at any one time.
A Personal Perspective on Confronting the Adversary
When asked about his ability to negotiate directly from emissaries from a head of state in the Russian government who has been willing to expend more than a million-plus of his own men to conquer its neighbor, Kyslytsya, also a former UN ambassador, offered his response.
He told that he'd had years of practice.
"I witnessed much worse. I served a five-year term in New York, a portion prior to the full-scale invasion. I would sit in the room with the adversary on a regular basis."
One evening is etched in his recollection: the eve of the invasion.
In the middle of an emergency Security Council session, convened to discuss the looming threat in Ukraine, the diplomat got word that his homeland was under attack.
At the same time, far away to the eastward in Kyiv, the first distant detonations were heard as Russia's all-out assault on the nation began.
During moments of intense drama, the ambassador attempted to persuade his Russian counterpart, Vassily Nebenzia, to call his superior, the Russian foreign minister, to obtain assurances that Moscow's troops would not invade.
"I have stated all that I am aware of now," Nebenzia responded, according to Kyslytsya. "I will not wake the minister at this time."
The world changed at that moment. Kyslytsya stayed at the United Nations for another three years before going back to Kyiv.
The Road Ahead
Should the delegations reconvene in Switzerland on Thursday, he'll be there, still working through the details and mechanics of a ceasefire but waiting all the while for the most important element of the jigsaw to fall into place.
"The war might be ended by just a single order of an individual to his military chief of staff," he said.
"However, the Russian president [Vladimir Putin] is not up to ending the war at present."